Author: Katie Replogle

Harry L. Horton, Millionaire New York Banker

Throughout their respective histories, the Athens and Sheshequin Universalist Societies have received donations from people who were, as far as I can tell, never members of either congregation.  Most of these non-member donors were local residents, but in 1895 one donation came from a wealthy and prominent New York City financier. In 1893 the trustees … Continue reading Harry L. Horton, Millionaire New York Banker

Rev. James Martin Peebles, Universalist Turned Spiritualist

In an earlier post about Sheshequin Universalist Society member O. H. P. Kinney, I noted that Kinney had turned to spiritualism later in life.  A disproportionate number of spiritualists in the nineteenth century were former Universalists, including a sizable number of Universalist ministers.  One Universalist minister who later became famous as a spiritualist served the … Continue reading Rev. James Martin Peebles, Universalist Turned Spiritualist

O. H. P. Kinney on Women’s Suffrage, 1867

In 1867 New York State held a Constitutional Convention for the purpose of examining the existing constitution and proposing changes.  Sheshequin Universalist Society member O. H. P. Kinney, well-known in Tioga County, N. Y., as the editor of the Waverly Advocate, was selected as that county’s delegate to the convention. Kinney was an avid proponent … Continue reading O. H. P. Kinney on Women’s Suffrage, 1867

What Is Heaven?

As noted in my last blog, Sheshequin Universalist Society member O. H. P. Kinney was a regular contributor to the Elmira Sunday Telegram in the early 1880s.  His weekly “Short Sunday Sermons” were published under the pen name “Peter Klaus.” One of his more trenchant sermons about orthodox Christian doctrine appeared in the Aug. 15, … Continue reading What Is Heaven?

Who Was “Peter Klaus”?

In the early 1880s, the Elmira Sunday Telegram featured a regular column entitled “Our Short Sunday Sermon” by “Peter Klaus.”  The “sermons” offered a liberal religious perspective – usually critical, sometimes to the point of ridicule – on orthodox Christian doctrines. The original Peter Klaus was a character in a German legend who was the … Continue reading Who Was “Peter Klaus”?

Far from the Tree

Children do not always adopt the faith of their parents, even when the parent is a minister. After he was converted to Universalism by Noah Murray in 1793, the Rev. Moses Park began preaching universal salvation to his Baptist congregation.  Sheshequin Universalist Society member W. H. H. Gore recalled: “[Park’s] congregation approved of the new … Continue reading Far from the Tree